We challenged Nicole to turn one mystery ingredient—hot dogs—into three brand-new recipes using a fully stocked kitchen and zero prep time. From recipe concept to final plate, Nicole walks through her creative process and proves there’s no challenge too weird (or too wiener-y) for her to handle.
She starts with a breakfast classic reimagined: a Hot Dog Pancake Casserole that’s sweet, savory, and surprisingly comforting. Next, she’s tasked with creating a wedding-worthy dish (for 100 people!) and pulls off a viral-inspired Garlic Bread Mini Hot Dog Station—with a guest appearance and taste test from Allrecipes’ own Natalie.
Finally, the real wildcard: dessert. Nicole channels candied bacon energy into a Caramelized Hot Dog Banana Sundae that’s bold, sweet, and shockingly good. Whether you’re here for the recipes or the reactions, this hot dog challenge brings the creativity.
Timestamps:
0:00 – Nicole Opens the Mystery Box
0:24 – Hot Dog Pancake Breakfast Casserole (Breakfast Challenge)
6:15 – Garlic Bread Mini Hot Dog Station (Wedding Challenge)
13:30 – Caramelized Hot Dog Banana Sundae (Dessert Challenge)
_________
Allrecipes Magazine is now available!
U.S. subscribers, subscribe here: http://armagazine.com/subscribenow
Canadian subscribers, subscribe here: http://themeredithstore.ca/p-282-allrecipes-subscription.aspx
Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/Allrecipes
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allrecipes/
Pinterest: https://www.pinterest.com/allrecipes/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@allrecipes








Nichole, You are a Gem. Love your personality and creativity.
Hint: if you're going to boil your dogs start with cold water, put dogs in. Bring to a boil, turn heat off the heat and let sit for 6 minutes. No matter the brand they will plump and be tastier…
Girl! Those Hawaiian pigs in a blanket…yaaasss!! 🤟
This is off the subject but where did she get that cute shirt?!?
the candied hot dogs over "sweet corn ice cream" would have been interesting (without the bananas). Loved the recipes 🙂
Starch spelled wrong!😂
"startch"…I'm a little embarrassed for y'all. I'll have to revisit this at another time. 😉
I just discovered her channel and I've been enjoying it. However, I love hot dogs 🌭 but not these recipes!
I say "A+"! Great job, Professional Chef or not!!! 👏
I definitely want to try the mini fancy hotdogs.
The dessert gave me an idea, make donuts with can biscuits with a maple glaze and your caramelized chopped hotdogs to go on top.